B_PE_01 Fail -- The values of PMCEID0_EL0, PMCR_EL0 are different on cores with different architectures in DynamIQ SoC

[magicse7en]

Since the SoC is DynamIQ architecture(e.g., cortex-a720 + cortex-x4), the values of PMCEID0_E0 and PMCR_EL0 differ between cortex-a720 and cortex-x4, causing the B_PE_01 test to fail.

Reg compare failed for PE index=4 for Register: PMCEID0_EL0
Current PE value = 0xF0F1A7F7BFF7F3F Other PE value = 0xF0F1A7F7FFF6F3F
Failed on PE - 4
B_PE_01
Checkpoint -- 1 : Result: FAIL
END

Any ideas?

[samerhaj]

The first rule in the BSA specification states that:

"RB_PE_01 All PEs are architecturally symmetric except for the permitted exceptions listed in Section A."

Section A has table 18, which shows the permitted differences for systems composed of heterogeneous PEs, such as big.LITTLE. These variations are not expected to be perceived as architectural differences by a general purpose OS.

PMCEID0_E0 and PMCR_EL0 are not in that list, which explains the failure.

[magicse7en]

The first rule in the BSA specification states that:

"RB_PE_01 All PEs are architecturally symmetric except for the permitted exceptions listed in Section A."

Section A has table 18, which shows the permitted differences for systems composed of heterogeneous PEs, such as big.LITTLE. These variations are not expected to be perceived as architectural differences by a general purpose OS.

PMCEID0_E0 and PMCR_EL0 are not in that list, which explains the failure.

Thanks for the reply.
Yes, I noticed the table 18 in the BSA specification. However, after reading the cortex-a720 and cortex-x4 TRMs:

• cortex-x4 supports ID26 (refer to Table A-332 in section A7.3 of TRM), but cortex-a720 doesn't support it (refer to Table A-251 in section A5.3)
• cortex-x4 doesn't support ID12, but cortex-a720 supports it.

I'm just curious if this heterogeneous PEs like cortex-a720+cortex-x4 are not BSA compliant?

[sunnywang-arm]

@magicse7en
Could you also provide the value of PMCR_EL0 in cortex-a720 and cortex-x4? there is no details about PMCR_EL0 so we don't know where the difference is.

[magicse7en]

@magicse7en Could you also provide the value of PMCR_EL0 in cortex-a720 and cortex-x4? there is no details about PMCR_EL0 so we don't know where the difference is.

The main difference is that the PMCR_EL0 bit[15:11] (indicate the number of event counters implemented), the number of event counters of cortex-a720 and cortex-x4 are diffferent.

[sunnywang-arm]

Thanks, @magicse7en

According to the TRMs for a720 and x5 (the links below), PMCR_EL0 bit[15:11] are reserved and the reset values for both a720 and x5 PMCR_EL0 bit[15:10] are the same (all 0s). Could you confirm that the difference is in [15:11]? It looks like the difference could only occur in bits [9][7][5].

• https://developer.arm.com/documentation/102530/0001/External-registers/External-PMU-registers-summary/PMCR-EL0--Performance-Monitors-Control-Register
• https://developer.arm.com/documentation/102484/0001/ext-registers/External-PMU-registers-summary/PMCR-EL0--Performance-Monitors-Control-Register

[magicse7en]

Hi @sunnywang-arm,
I think the PMCR_EL0 is the AArch64_pmcr_el0, not ext_pmcr_el0. right?

• https://developer.arm.com/documentation/102484/0001/AArch64-registers/AArch64-Performance-Monitors-registers-summary/PMCR-EL0--Performance-Monitors-Control-Register?lang=en
• https://developer.arm.com/documentation/102530/0001/AArch64-registers/AArch64-Performance-Monitors-registers-summary/PMCR-EL0--Performance-Monitors-Control-Register?lang=en

The A720 PMCR_EL0 value: 0xA0E0
The X4 PMCE_EL0 value: 0xF8E0

[sunnywang-arm]

Yes, you're right. Thanks for pointing that out, @magicse7en. We'll also check this.

[hrw]

On RK3588 (A76 + A55) registers also differ on PE 4-7:

        PE Index: 4, ID_AA64PFR0_EL1    : 0x1100000011111112    FAIL
          Masked Primary PE Value : 0x0000000011112222 
          Masked Current PE Value : 0x1100000011111112 

        PE Index: 4, PMCEID1_EL0        : 0x0000000000F2AE7F    FAIL
          Masked Primary PE Value : 0x0000000001F0AE7F 
          Masked Current PE Value : 0x0000000000F2AE7F 
        PE Index: 4, PMCR_EL0           : 0x0000000000000000    FAIL
          Masked Primary PE Value : 0x0000000041453000 
          Masked Current PE Value : 0x0000000000000000 

        PE Index: 4, ID_PFR1_EL1        : 0x10010000    FAIL
          Masked Primary PE Value : 0x10011011 
          Masked Current PE Value : 0x10010000 

PE 0-3 are A55, 4-7 are A76