Most common use cases of VBET I forsee

[joewheaton]

@philipbaileynar, the value in VBET beyond panning and zooming and exploring will be:

1. Using VBET output as a starting point, and choosing a threshold and then "editing' that polygon based on other subjective and judement based manual evidence.
2. Re-running VBET with my own LiDAR for my segment (credit card please)
3. Re-running VBET with my own manually edited reach segment network geometry (credit card please initially)
4. Re-running or filtering VBET with my own selection of what part of network to use
5. Re-running VBET with my own loaded network (credit card please)
6. Re-running VBET with my own parameterization

My big questions are:

1. Which of above scare you?
2. Do you see away for any of above to be part of same Riverscapes VBET project, as different realizations (I see 1 as adding a new realization of an output; 2 - 6 as new realization of input)

[joewheaton]

Reminder... @philipbaileynar

[joewheaton]

@philipbaileynar, this was from April. You and I have discussed this a lot since then. Please consider how and if are thinking has shifted since then and propose the answer here that you think we are dealing with in:

• A) Year 1 BLM Deliverable of Commercial Grade VBET
• B) Year 2 BLM Upgrade to Commercial Grade VBET
• C) Riverscapes Studio - Desktop QGIS
• D) Riverscapes Studio - Web (Year 3 BLM)?
• E) RAVE consumption

My re-read is that of the use cases identified in April

• 1. → Maps to B and C and later D
• 2. → Maps to D?
• 3. → Maybe slips between cracks as custom request... Maybe Year 4 Riverscapes Studio - Web?
• 4. → Maps to D (i.e. FY 2023)
• 5. → Maybe slips between cracks as custom request... Maybe Year 4 Riverscapes Studio - Web?

I think we've added a some new use cases focused very much around the "My Riverscapes" idea of 1, but really user-centric.

@nick4rivers you should see this too as it tracks what you and @KellyMWhitehead have already done in RIPT.

[joewheaton]

@shelbysawyer you should be reading this and tracking.

[shelbysawyer]

@philipbaileynar, this was from April. You and I have discussed this a lot since then. Please consider how and if our thinking has shifted since then and propose the answer here that you think we are dealing with in:

• A) Year 1 BLM Deliverable of Commercial Grade VBET
• B) Year 2 BLM Upgrade to Commercial Grade VBET
• C) Riverscapes Studio - Desktop QGIS
• D) Riverscapes Studio - Web (Year 3 BLM)?
• E) RAVE consumption

My re-read is that of the use cases identified in April

• i. → Maps to B and C and later D
• ii. → Maps to D?
• iii. → Maybe slips between cracks as custom request... Maybe Year 4 Riverscapes Studio - Web?
• iv. → Maps to D (i.e. FY 2023)
• v. → Maybe slips between cracks as custom request... Maybe Year 4 Riverscapes Studio - Web?

I think we've added a some new use cases focused very much around the "My Riverscapes" idea of 1, but really user-centric.

@joewheaton I'm not fully understanding what you're laying out here. What are the 'i-v' bullets referring to? The original list, numbered '1-6'?

[joewheaton]

This conversation has moved to UI Specs in #389 and #390