Annotation Preview lists additional "enabled by GENEPRODUCT" in extensions

[suzialeksander]

Some of the imported SGD YeastPathways have additional entities in the extensions. In gomodel:YeastPathways_TREDEG-YEAST-PWY, there is an annotation to ATH1 but there's a loose enabled_by(NTH1 Scer) in the extensions, and vice versa. This might have something to do with branched/cyclical pathways.

Additional oddity: ATH1 and NTH1 appear in GE, Alliance Pathway Preview. Visual Pathway Editor doesn't mention NTH1.

tagging @dustine32

[dustine32]

Here's the whole model on Noctua prod:

You can see each of the two enabled_by annotations (ATH1, NTH1) reflecting each other in their extensions fields.

Maybe a simple fix is to disallow enabled_by from being emitted in the GPAD export extensions column?

[dustine32]

@balhoff If we wanted to remove enabled_by relations from Noctua GPAD export extensions column is this the line we'd need to take out?

minerva/minerva-converter/src/main/resources/org/geneontology/minerva/legacy/sparql/gpad-extensions.rq

Line 75 in a6a9d0b

<http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/RO_0002333>

Also tagging @vanaukenk @pgaudet as I feel this is executive decision-level stuff.

[pgaudet]

Discussion on the managers call:

There should not be 2 enablers, this violates ShEx.

Options to fix this would be

• to create two separate models, one for each enabler,
• or two individuals in the same model

If the model is fixed, then there will not be exported in the extensions.

Pascale

[suzialeksander]

note, i've manually fixed the model above. SGD is going to proceed to manually edit these models in Noctua production.

[suzialeksander]

For the above model, the error is

Violations
This feature is currently under development, with more user friendly error reports coming. If you have questions about the error messages you're seeing, please create a [ticket](https://github.com/geneontology/noctua).
[
   {
      "shape": "obo:go/shapes/MolecularFunction",
      "constraints": [
         {
            "property": "RO:0002333",
            "cardinality": "[0; 1]",
            "nobjects": 2
         }
      ]
   }
]