You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
The current MIDI CC/NRPN nadling implementation have inconsistencies.
Just an example for OSC A MSB/LSB handling:
OSC A LSB (CC102) sent before MSB (CC54) might be ignored, i.e. only the CC54 might be reflected in program dump afetr CC102/CC54 sequence. The CC54/CC102 sequence seems to work consisnent in that term. It should be fixed or reflected in MIDI implementation document similar to *2-1
The valies itself are inconsistent: for the OSC A with 0....16363 range (changeing the range to 0...1023 change nothing) in the header parameter definition, sending 0...1023 in higher 10 bits of 14-bit CC54/CC102 qill result in the following OSC A valie in program dump:
0...512 - values are in par
513-1023 - values are 1 less, except of the next:
522 and every 8th up to 1018 are 9 less
setting lower 4 bits of LSB (CC102) just changes the reusult just only for 1023
UPD; all of the above is applicable to Param NRPN's as well. I.e.
despite of the *2-1, sending CC38 0, CC6 0 and got 7 in the dump from the last CC38 value
header parameter range definition affects the dump value, but the 14-bit CC value is decimated to 10-bits. For both 0...16383 and 0...1023 p.2 of the above is also the case.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
dukesrg
changed the title
NTS-1 mkII: MIDI sen/receive parameters value inconsistency
NTS-1 mkII: MIDI send/receive parameter values inconsistency
Jul 10, 2024
The current MIDI CC/NRPN nadling implementation have inconsistencies.
Just an example for OSC A MSB/LSB handling:
The result is reproducible, test result sheet available here:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1xZaxXdUIRua6vdT9HF-SRPVPFKR3oh125u0vGNMLQ0g/edit?usp=sharing
UPD; all of the above is applicable to Param NRPN's as well. I.e.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: