diff --git a/proposals/3861-next-generation-auth.md b/proposals/3861-next-generation-auth.md index 60d6e387e2..710bb2c20d 100644 --- a/proposals/3861-next-generation-auth.md +++ b/proposals/3861-next-generation-auth.md @@ -153,9 +153,8 @@ This usually implies a contractual relationship between the service provider and This has been a notorious problem with [OAuth 2.0 in email protocols][thunderbird-oauth2], where email clients are forced to register their applications with each email provider, giving the email provider the right to reject any application. -The goal of this proposal is to keep the ecosystem open by clearly defining how clients register themselves dynamically with the homeserver. -This won't prevent the homeserver from rejecting clients arbitrarily, but this was already the case with UIA. -On the contrary, this proposal will provide homeserver operators greater visibility into which clients are being used, helping with decisions to approve third-party clients. +The goal of this proposal is to keep the ecosystem open by clearly defining how clients dynamically register themselves with the homeserver. +While this won't prevent a homeserver from arbitrarily rejecting clients (which is already possible with UIA based on the client's user-agent string or redirect URI, for example), this proposal will provide homeserver operators greater visibility into which clients are being used, aiding decisions to approve third-party clients. [thunderbird-oauth2]: https://wiki.mozilla.org/Thunderbird:Autoconfiguration:ConfigFileFormat#OAuth2