Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Add ability to parse variables in expression from context for CEL #716

Open
vincent-pli opened this issue Mar 4, 2021 · 7 comments
Open
Labels
kind/feature Categorizes issue or PR as related to a new feature. lifecycle/frozen Indicates that an issue or PR should not be auto-closed due to staleness.

Comments

@vincent-pli
Copy link
Member

Feature request

The CEL is a great feature, we plan to adopt in our project, but seems it can not support parse expression which include other variables, for example:

  params:
    - name: name
      value: "'hello'"
    - name: types
      value: "type(name)"

see the name has been defined in first param and expect to used in second param.
I guess this is not required in when express, but useful in other scenario.

In our case, we will set some initialize variables in some runtime storage (maybe a runtime created CM), and in expression, we will use these variables.

Use case

@vincent-pli vincent-pli added the kind/feature Categorizes issue or PR as related to a new feature. label Mar 4, 2021
@vincent-pli
Copy link
Member Author

@jerop

@tekton-robot
Copy link

Issues go stale after 90d of inactivity.
Mark the issue as fresh with /remove-lifecycle stale with a justification.
Stale issues rot after an additional 30d of inactivity and eventually close.
If this issue is safe to close now please do so with /close with a justification.
If this issue should be exempted, mark the issue as frozen with /lifecycle frozen with a justification.

/lifecycle stale

Send feedback to tektoncd/plumbing.

@tekton-robot tekton-robot added the lifecycle/stale Denotes an issue or PR has remained open with no activity and has become stale. label Jun 2, 2021
@tekton-robot
Copy link

Stale issues rot after 30d of inactivity.
Mark the issue as fresh with /remove-lifecycle rotten with a justification.
Rotten issues close after an additional 30d of inactivity.
If this issue is safe to close now please do so with /close with a justification.
If this issue should be exempted, mark the issue as frozen with /lifecycle frozen with a justification.

/lifecycle rotten

Send feedback to tektoncd/plumbing.

@tekton-robot tekton-robot added lifecycle/rotten Denotes an issue or PR that has aged beyond stale and will be auto-closed. and removed lifecycle/stale Denotes an issue or PR has remained open with no activity and has become stale. labels Jul 2, 2021
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Aug 26, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have
identified three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in tektoncd#716
and tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declate runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and Pipelines. Read more in tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which
is misleading to some users.

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Aug 26, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have
identified three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in tektoncd#716
and tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declate runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which
is misleading to some users.

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Aug 26, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Aug 26, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Aug 26, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Aug 27, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Aug 27, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Aug 27, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Aug 27, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Aug 27, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Aug 27, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Aug 27, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Aug 27, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Aug 27, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Aug 30, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Aug 31, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Aug 31, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Aug 31, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Aug 31, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Aug 31, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Aug 31, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Sep 1, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Sep 1, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Sep 1, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Sep 1, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Sep 1, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Sep 2, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Sep 2, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Sep 2, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Sep 2, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Sep 2, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Sep 3, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Sep 3, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Sep 3, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Sep 3, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Sep 7, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Sep 7, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Sep 7, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Sep 8, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
@tekton-robot
Copy link

Rotten issues close after 30d of inactivity.
Reopen the issue with /reopen with a justification.
Mark the issue as fresh with /remove-lifecycle rotten with a justification.
If this issue should be exempted, mark the issue as frozen with /lifecycle frozen with a justification.

/close

Send feedback to tektoncd/plumbing.

@tekton-robot
Copy link

@tekton-robot: Closing this issue.

In response to this:

Rotten issues close after 30d of inactivity.
Reopen the issue with /reopen with a justification.
Mark the issue as fresh with /remove-lifecycle rotten with a justification.
If this issue should be exempted, mark the issue as frozen with /lifecycle frozen with a justification.

/close

Send feedback to tektoncd/plumbing.

Instructions for interacting with me using PR comments are available here. If you have questions or suggestions related to my behavior, please file an issue against the kubernetes/test-infra repository.

@jerop
Copy link
Member

jerop commented Oct 14, 2021

/reopen
/lifecycle frozen

work in progress in #784

@tekton-robot
Copy link

@jerop: Reopened this issue.

In response to this:

/reopen
/lifecycle frozen

work in progress in #784

Instructions for interacting with me using PR comments are available here. If you have questions or suggestions related to my behavior, please file an issue against the kubernetes/test-infra repository.

@tekton-robot tekton-robot reopened this Oct 14, 2021
@tekton-robot tekton-robot added lifecycle/frozen Indicates that an issue or PR should not be auto-closed due to staleness. and removed lifecycle/rotten Denotes an issue or PR that has aged beyond stale and will be auto-closed. labels Oct 14, 2021
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Oct 19, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
jerop added a commit to jerop/experimental that referenced this issue Oct 19, 2021
We introduced CEL Custom Tasks to experiment with using an expression
language with Tekton Pipelines.

Given feedback from the past several months of usage, we have identified
three main current challenges:
- CEL custom tasks do not take variables for the CEL environment.
As such, users cannot evaluate CEL expressions given specific variables
or in specific context. For example, as described in
tektoncd#716 and
tektoncd/community#403, a user needed to
declare runtime storage variables in the CEL environment.
- CEL custom tasks are not a CRD thus making them unreusable across
different Runs and PipelineRuns. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).
- CEL custom tasks take the CEL expressions through Parameters which is
misleading to some users. Read more in
tektoncd/community#314 (review).

To address the above challenges, this change introduces a CRD for CEL
Custom Tasks, which takes CEL expressions and CEL environment variables.
With this change:
- CEL custom tasks now take variables for the CEL environment
- CEL custom tasks are reusable across different Runs and PipelineRuns
- CEL custom tasks take expressions through its own field

Closes tektoncd/community#403
Closes tektoncd#716
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
kind/feature Categorizes issue or PR as related to a new feature. lifecycle/frozen Indicates that an issue or PR should not be auto-closed due to staleness.
Projects
Status: Todo
3 participants