Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

New Map: Chaotica #362

Open
wants to merge 6 commits into
base: master
Choose a base branch
from
Open

New Map: Chaotica #362

wants to merge 6 commits into from

Conversation

mrtechtroid
Copy link

@mrtechtroid mrtechtroid commented Aug 27, 2024

New Map: Chaotica

  • For Nade Fight, and Classes
  • Uses Team Yellow and Purple. (CAUTION: Please use the latest fork of CTF, and not from ContentDB since Team Yellow is not updated there)
  • Low Gravity - To Jump Platforms.
  • Small Map.
  • Double Team Chest

Would love your feedback on this map.

(More chests will be added if necessary)

screenshot

@Themostrandom
Copy link
Contributor

image
Several problems celon moi: Il y a 2 teams chest cela peut causer des bugs et n'est pas utile(mais surtout cela double la quantité de stuff stocké et cela correspond a votre map) The size of the map is 115*55, and there are not enough chests for a map I call chaotic. I suggest adding a block at the player's spawn.
I like the idea of these platforms, but I'd have put more over a greater distance (x,y,z axis). --> It comes back to the problem of map size. There are no minerals, but that's not a real problem because there's no classic mode (in my opinion, 5 diamonds on each side would be good for class axes).

I like the idea of your map but the main problem for me is the size of the map and the 2 chest teams.

@mrtechtroid
Copy link
Author

mrtechtroid commented Aug 28, 2024

Hi there, @Themostrandom
The Two Chests are "Intentional" unless they break something in game.
Its supposed to be a small map, for lesser no of players. (Same size as "Sams Mansion).
I will be adding more chests to the map to make it better.

Regarding the distance between platforms, it is kept lower to allow players to actually be able to jump on the other platform without missing.

@SoulS33ker
Copy link
Contributor

SoulS33ker commented Aug 29, 2024

must change:
1.the team zones are selected wrong,should be an easy fix to re-select them

teamzone.mp4

others opinions:
1.we usually do 5x5 protected area around the flag,if map managers agree with the small area of your spawns then its fine
2.any reason for the thin map?
3.i see no problems with the extra team storage space 👍
4.The pvp-junkies in ctf would be mad i think,as there's less space of pvp,towering would be useless,might fall to death,but personally i would love to see this map and new type of pvp being born here.

yapping:
what would be a cool addition would a short fueled rocket boots so even if players fall they have final chance to survive,or double jump (mid -air type as seen in mc hypixel)
yet, how about addin lava floor 1 block deep instead of kill node,something to survive even if u fall

@SoulS33ker
Copy link
Contributor

i would also like to how did u choose the locations for the platforms,are they calculated strategic locations or so was it just random?

@mrtechtroid
Copy link
Author

@SoulS33ker

  • I'll fix the team zones later.
  • If there are objections with 5x5 area, ill try fixing. (once again lets put some chaos)
  • Same size(sligthly larger in width) than Sams Mansion
  • Platforms were randomly placed, with additionally making sure that every platform can be accessed by at least one platform without boost, and at least 2 with boost.

@SoulS33ker
Copy link
Contributor

@mrtechtroid
could it be difficult to capture flag due to :
1.narrowness of map,not providing a meta to sneak into the base(i dont belive in teamwork)
2.extra base making materials in 2nd team chest

we dont have a thin map to back up my points thats why i want one of these thin maps in,sams mansion provides tunnels and enough cover for players to escape the eye & sneak in (it is to be noted it is a speed run map,not really that well liked)

@mrtechtroid
Copy link
Author

@Themostrandom @SoulS33ker @HobbitPower

  • Fixed team zones.
  • Added ores on the map now. (Wanted to ask if its enough to be allowed to enable classic now)

@AnonomousAccount
Copy link
Contributor

AnonomousAccount commented Sep 6, 2024

Gameplay Concerns:

Remember, players won't go places that have no benefit to their gameplay. Such will happen with the higher platforms. I also see this map as being frustrating (falling to your death and losing all your items tends to be).

The gameplay I would expect would be each team bridging in a perfectly straight line towards the middle and the whole match being bridge PVP. While some enjoy this, there is no alternate option. With 20 or more players online, this map would most likely last hours, the items dwindling as they fall into the void.

The concept might work, but this current approach will not

@AnonomousAccount
Copy link
Contributor

Also, low gravity doesn't work that well in nades. Nades need to collide with an object to be effective, and if players are flying through the air, they will be easily not be able to be hit.

Bassicaly: Nades + Low Gravity = Melee fight

@mrtechtroid
Copy link
Author

@AnonomousAccount you do NOT die instantly on hitting the floor, if you jump instantly as soon you fall down, you will reach one of the lower platforms, with the help of ladders.
Players will go to higher platforms if they intend on sneaking and getting the flag.
Nades have an radius where they will give damage to players, and there is always void bombs to bring you down.
This map is again meant for smaller player sizes.

@AnonomousAccount
Copy link
Contributor

It's maps like these in which I wish we had a testing period

@HobbitPower
Copy link
Contributor

HobbitPower commented Sep 18, 2024

@mrtechtroid

  • Please fix the team zones. I get teleported back when I'm one block away from the red barrier.

  • Add a roof

  • I would recommend removing the second team chest.

  • I like the idea of changing gravity as it ties the platforms in better. But I would disable the map for nade fight then. It's not enabled for classic btw?

  • The hint is completely unnecessary. You could use it instead to point out the ores.

  • Speaking of ores: I would rather make the ceiling destructible instead of the wool (floor and outer walls).

  • Small things that don't necessarily need to be adjusted, but can be: When the red barrier disappears there is a gap in the kill nodes. Also a block in the outer barrier is missing.

  • It's an interesting concept, very experimental. Quite small (ik it's intentional). It is very possible that many people will not like the map though. I would agree to a test phase if you are willing to make changes, given enough feedback.

@mrtechtroid
Copy link
Author

mrtechtroid commented Oct 6, 2024

Changes performed:

  • Centered the flag now and added more symmetry.
  • Made the center 2x4 blocks in the middle/central section breakable.
  • Fixed the barriers, outer walls, and added the upper roof.
  • Added all three modes to be allowed for the map.

No changes on:

  • No of team chests per team is still 2.
  • Size of the map is still the same.
    image

@HobbitPower
Copy link
Contributor

The biggest bugs have been fixed, so the action needed label has been removed for the time being.
Feedback still welcome, so no final approval yet.
As already said: Interesting concept, although I could imagine that many might not like it (platforms, gravity, size of the map). Personally, I also think that the map is quite small and that speedruns are possible, at least in nade-fight.

So I rather see an approval for a test phase on the main server. If there is too much negative feedback, changes will have to be made.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

5 participants