Logstash Filter Verifier

• Introduction
• Installing
• Standalone and Daemon mode (since Version 2.0)
• Examples
  • Syslog messages
  • Beats messages
  • JSON messages
  • Version 2.0 (Daemon mode only)
• Test case file reference
  • Standalone mode / Logstash Filter Verifier before version 2.0
  • Daemon mode
    • Plugin mock
• Migrating to the current test case file format
• Notes
  • The --sockets flag
  • The --logstash-arg flag
  • Logstash compatibility
    • Standalone mode
    • Daemon mode
  • Windows compatibility
  • Plugin ID (Daemon mode)
  • Logstash Plugins
  • @metadata field
• Development
  • Dependencies
  • Run Integration Tests
• Known limitations and future work
• License

Introduction

The Logstash program for collecting and processing logs from is popular and commonly used to process e.g. syslog messages and HTTP logs.

Apart from ingesting log events and sending them to one or more destinations it can transform the events in various ways, including extracting discrete fields from flat blocks of text, joining multiple physical lines into singular logical events, parsing JSON and XML, and deleting unwanted events. It uses its own domain-specific configuration language to describe both inputs, outputs, and the filters that should be applied to events.

Writing the filter configurations necessary to parse events isn't difficult for someone with basic programming skills, but verifying that the filters do what you expect can be tedious; especially when you tweak existing filters and want to make sure that all kinds of logs will continue to be processed as before. If you get something wrong you might have millions of incorrectly parsed events before you realize your mistake.

This is where Logstash Filter Verifier comes in. It lets you define test case files containing lines of input together with the expected output from Logstash. Pass one of more such test case files to Logstash Filter Verifier together with all of your Logstash filter configuration files and it'll run Logstash for you and verify that Logstash actually returns what you expect.

Before you can run Logstash Filter Verifier you need to install it. After covering that, let's start with a simple example and follow up with reference documentation.

Installing

All releases of Logstash Filter Verifier are published in binary form for the most common platforms at github.com/magnusbaeck/logstash-filter-verifier/releases.

If you need to run the program on other platforms or if you want to modify the program yourself you can build and use it on any platform for which a recent Go compiler is available. Pretty much any platform where Logstash runs should be fine, including Windows.

Many Linux distributions make some version of the Go compiler easily installable, but otherwise you can download and install the latest version. The source code is written to use Go modules for dependency management. You need at least least Go 1.16.x.

To just build an executable file you don't need anything but the Go compiler; just clone the Logstash Filter Verifier repository and run go build from the root directory of the cloned repostiory. If successful you'll find an executable in the current directory.

One drawback of this is that the program won't get stamped with the correct version number, so logstash-filter-verifier --version will say "unknown"). To address this and make it easy to run tests and static checks you need GNU make and other GNU tools.

The makefile can also be used to install Logstash Filter Verifier centrally, by default in /usr/local/bin but you can change that by modifying the PREFIX variable. For example, to install it in $HOME/bin (which is probably in your shell's path) you can issue the following command:

$ make install PREFIX=$HOME

Standalone and Daemon mode (since Version 2.0)

Since version 2.0, there are two different modes, Logstash Filter Verifier can be operated in.

1. Standalone: In this mode, for each test run a fresh instance of Logstash is started in the background by Logstash Filter Verifier. If a user wants to frequently execute test cases, this might be slow and tedious.
   This has been to only mode available in versions prior to 2.0.
2. Daemon: In this mode, Logstash Filter Verifier is executed twice in parallel (preferably in two different shells). One instance is the daemon. The daemon starts and controls the Logstash instances (there might be multiple). This daemon process is normally left running for the time the user is working on the Logstash configuration and testing it with Logstash Filter Verifier.
   For each execution of the test cases, another instance Logstash Filter Verifier is started (client). The client collects the current state of the Logstash configuration as well as the test cases and passes them to the daemon. The daemon reloads the configuration in one of the running Logstash instances, executes the test cases and returns the result back to the client. The client shows the results to the user and exits, while the daemon continues to run and waits for the next client to submit a test execution job.

Examples

The examples that follow build upon each other and do not only show how to use Logstash Filter Verifier to test that particular kind of log. They also highlight how to deal with different features in logs.

Syslog messages

Logstash is often used to parse syslog messages, so let's use that as a first example.

Test case files are in JSON or YAML format and contain a single object with about a handful of supported properties.

Sample with JSON format:

{
  "fields": {
    "type": "syslog"
  },
  "testcases": [
    {
      "input": [
        "Oct  6 20:55:29 myhost myprogram[31993]: This is a test message"
      ],
      "expected": [
        {
          "@timestamp": "2015-10-06T20:55:29.000Z",
          "host": "myhost",
          "message": "This is a test message",
          "pid": 31993,
          "program": "myprogram",
          "type": "syslog"
        }
      ]
    }
  ]
}

Sample with YAML format:

fields:
  type: "syslog"
testcases:
  - input:
      - "Oct  6 20:55:29 myhost myprogram[31993]: This is a test message"
    expected:
      - "@timestamp": "2015-10-06T20:55:29.000Z"
        host: "myhost"
        message: "This is a test message"
        pid: 31993
        program: "myprogram"
        type: "syslog"

Most Logstash configurations contain filters for multiple kinds of logs and uses conditions on field values to select which filters to apply. Those field values are typically set in the input plugins. To make Logstash treat the test events correctly we can "inject" additional field values to make the test events look like the real events to Logstash. In this example, fields.type is set to "syslog" which means that the input events in the test cases in this file will have that in their type field when they're passed to Logstash.

Next, in input, we define a single test string that we want to feed through Logstash, and the expected array contains a one-element array with the event we expect Logstash to emit for the given input.

The testcases array can contain multiple objects with input and expected keys. For example, if we change the example above to

fields:
  type: "syslog"
testcases:
  - input:
      - "Oct  6 20:55:29 myhost myprogram[31993]: This is a test message"
    expected:
      - "@timestamp": "2015-10-06T20:55:29.000Z"
        host: "myhost"
        message: "This is a test message"
        pid: 31993
        program: "myprogram"
        type: "syslog"
  - input:
      - "Oct  6 20:55:29 myhost myprogram: This is a test message"
    expected:
      - "@timestamp": "2015-10-06T20:55:29.000Z"
        host: "myhost"
        message: "This is a test message"
        program: "myprogram"
        type: "syslog"

we also test syslog messages that lack the bracketed pid after the program name.

Note that UTC is the assumed timezone for input events to avoid different behavior depending on the timezone of the machine where Logstash Filter Verifier happens to run. This won't affect time formats that include a timezone.

This command will run this test case file through Logstash Filter Verifier (replace all "path/to" with the actual paths to the files, obviously):

$ path/to/logstash-filter-verifier standalone path/to/syslog.json path/to/filters

If the test is successful, Logstash Filter Verifier will terminate with a zero exit code and (almost) no output. If the test fails it'll run diff -u (or some other command if you use the --diff-command flag) to compare the pretty-printed JSON representation of the expected and actual events.

The actual event emitted by Logstash will contain a @version field, but since that field isn't interesting it's ignored by default when reading the actual event. Hence we don't need to include it in the expected event either. Additional fields can be ignored with the ignore array property in the test case file (see details below).

Beats messages

In Beats you can also specify fields to control the behavior of the Logstash pipeline.
An example in Beats config might look like this:

- input_type: log
  paths: ["/var/log/work/*.log"]
  fields:
    type: openlog
- input_type: log
  paths: ["/var/log/trace/*.trc"]
  fields:
    type: trace

The Logstash configuration would then look like this to check the given field:

if ([fields][type] == "openlog") {
   Do something for type openlog

But, in order to test the behavior with LFV you have to give it like so:

{
  "fields": {
    "[fields][type]": "openlog"
  },

The reason is, that Beats is inserting by default declared fields under a root element fields, while the LFV is just considering it as a configuration option.
Alternatively you can tell Beats to insert the configured fields on root:

fields_under_root: true

JSON messages

I always prefer to configure applications to emit JSON objects whenever possible so that I don't have to write complex and/or ambiguous grok expressions. Here's an example:

{"message": "This is a test message", "client": "127.0.0.1", "host": "myhost", "time": "2015-10-06T20:55:29Z"}

When you feed events like this to Logstash it's likely that the input used will have its codec set to "json_lines". This is something we should mimic on the Logstash Filter Verifier side too. Use codec for that:

Sample with JSON format:

{
  "fields": {
    "type": "app"
  },
  "codec": "json_lines",
  "ignore": ["host"],
  "testcases": [
    {
      "input": [
        "{\"message\": \"This is a test message\", \"client\": \"127.0.0.1\", \"time\": \"2015-10-06T20:55:29Z\"}"
      ],
      "expected": [
        {
          "@timestamp": "2015-10-06T20:55:29.000Z",
          "client": "localhost",
          "clientip": "127.0.0.1",
          "message": "This is a test message",
          "type": "app"
        }
      ]
    }
  ]
}

Sample with YAML format:

fields:
  type: "app"
codec: "json_lines"
ignore:
  - "host"
testcases:
  - input:
      - >
        {
          "message": "This is a test message",
          "client": "127.0.0.1",
          "time": "2015-10-06T20:55:29Z"
        }
    expected:
      - "@timestamp": "2015-10-06T20:55:29.000Z"
        client: "localhost"
        clientip: "127.0.0.1"
        message: "This is a test message"
        type: "app"

There are a few points to be made here:

• The double quotes inside the string must be escaped when using JSON format. YAML files sometimes require quoting too; for example if the value starts with [ or { or if a numeric value should be forced to be parsed as a string.
• Together with the lack of a need to escape double quotes inside JSON strings, the use of > to create folded lines in the YAML representation makes the input JSON much easier to read.
• The filters being tested here use Logstash's dns filter to transform the IP address in the client field into a hostname and copy the original IP address into the clientip field. To avoid future problems and flaky tests, pick a hostname or IP address for the test case that will always resolve to the same thing. As in this example, localhost and 127.0.0.1 should be safe picks.
• If the input event doesn't contain a host field, Logstash will add such a field containing the name of the current host. To avoid test cases that behave differently depending on the host where they're run, we ignore that field with the ignore property.

Version 2.0 (Daemon mode only)

With version 2.0 of Logstash Filter Verifier (Daemon mode) some new features have been added:

• Export of @metadata:
  There is out of the box support to let Logstash Filter Verifier export the values in the (otherwise hidden) @metadata field of the event. This allows to write test cases, which take the values in the @metadata field into account. (see export_metadata in test case file reference)
• Pipeline configuration:
  Logstash Filter Verifier in Daemon mode accepts complete Logstash pipelines as configuration. This includes the localization of the Logstash configuration files through the paths provided in the pipelines.yml file and replacing all input and output filters with the respective parts to execute the tests.
• Multiple pipelines
  The pipeline configuration may consist of multiple pipelines, that might be linked (pipeline to pipeline communication) or independent pipelines.
• Plugin mock
  Plugin mock allows to replace (or remove) plugins in the Logstash configuration under test, that do not work during or that would potentially not produce the expected results test execution. Examples for such filter plugins are mainly plugins, that perform some sort of call out to a third party system, for example to look up data (elasticsearch, http, jdbc, memcached). In order to to be able to produce reproducible results in the test cases, these plugins can be replaced with mocks. In particular the mutate and the translate filters have proven to be helpful as replacements. Other use cases for mocks are:
  • replace filters, that operate on environment variables, that need to be changed between different test cases (see #120).
  • replace pipeline input and output plugins in order to test pipelines in isolation.

In order to execute a test case in daemon mode, first the daemon needs to be started (e.g. in its own terminal or shell):

$ path/to/logstash-filter-verifier daemon start

Next, a single test case run can be launched with (in second terminal/shell):

$ path/to/logstash-filter-verifier daemon run --pipeline path/to/pipelines.yml --pipeline-base base/path/of/logstash-configuration --testcase-dir path/to/testcases

The flag --pipeline-base is required, if the pipelines.yml file does use relative paths for the actual logstash pipeline configuration.

If the Logstash configuration under test does not contain id attributes for all plugins, the --add-missing-id flag instructs Logstash Filter Verifier to add the missing id attributes on the fly.

As an example, we can execute the basic_pipeline test case from this repository.

Let us assume, the following setup:

• The logstash filter verifier binary is available at /usr/local/bin/logstash-fitler-verifier.
• This repository is available at /tmp/logstash-filter-verifier (e.g. with git clone https://github.com/magnusbaeck/logstash-filter-verifier ).

The command to run the basic_pipeline example would look like this (the daemon needs to be started beforehand):

$ /usr/local/bin/logstash-fitler-verifier daemon run --pipeline /tmp/logstash-filter-verifier/testdata/basic_pipeline.yml --pipeline-base /tmp/logstash-filter-verifier/testdata/basic_pipeline --testcase-dir /tmp/logstash-filter-verifier/testdata/testcases/basic_pipeline --add-missing-id

More examples (e.g. multiple pipelines and plugin mock) can be found in the testcases/ folder of this repository.

Test case file reference

Standalone mode / Logstash Filter Verifier before version 2.0

Test case files are JSON files containing a single object. That object may have the following properties:

• codec: A string with the codec configuration of the input plugin used when executing the tests. This string will be included verbatim in the Logstash configuration so it could either be just the name of the codec plugin (normally line or json_lines) or include additional codec options like e.g. plain { charset => "ISO-8859-1" }.
• fields: An object containing the fields that all input messages should have. This is vital since filters typically are configured based on the event's type and/or tags. Scalar values (strings, numbers, and booleans) are supported, as are objects (containing scalars, arrays and nested objects), arrays of scalars and nested arrays. The only combination which is not allowed are objects within arrays. A shorthand for defining nested fields is to use the Logstash's field reference syntax ([field][subfield]), i.e. fields: {"[log][file][path]": "/tmp/test.log"} is equivalent to fields: {"log": {"file": {"path": "/tmp/test.log"}}}.
• ignore: An array with the names of the fields that should be removed from the events that Logstash emit. This is for example useful for dynamically generated fields whose contents can't be predicted and hardwired into the test case file. If you need to exclude individual subfields you can use Logstash's field reference syntax, i.e. [log][file][path] will exclude that field but keep other subfields of log like e.g. [log][level] and [log][file][line].
• testcases: An array of test case objects, each having the following contents:
  • input: An array with the lines of input (each line being a string) that should be fed to the Logstash process. If you use json_lines codec you can use Logstash's syntax reference syntax for fields in the JSON object, making {"message": "my message", "[log][file][path]": "/tmp/test.log"} equivalent to {"message": "my message", "log": {"file": {"path": "/tmp/test.log"}}}.
  • expected: An array of JSON objects with the events to be expected. They will be compared to the actual events produced by the Logstash process.
  • description: An optional textual description of the test case, e.g. useful as documentation. This text will be included in the program's progress messages.

Daemon mode

Test case files for the Daemon mode have the same fields as for Standalone mode with the following changes/additions

Additional fields:

• input_plugin: The unique ID of the input plugin in the tested configuration, where the test input is coming from. This is necessary, if a setup with multiple inputs is tested, which either have different codecs or are part of different pipelines.
• export_metadata: Controls if the metadata of the event processed by Logstash is returned. The metadata is contained in the field [@metadata] in the Logstash event. If the metadata is exported, the respective fields are compared with the expected result of the testcase as well. (default: false)
• export_outputs: Controls if the ID of the output, a particular event has emitted by, is kept in the event or not. If this is enabled, the expected event needs to contain a field named _lfv_out_passed which contains the ID of the Logstash output.
• testcases:
  • fields: Local fields, only added to the events of this test case. These fields overwrite global fields.

Ignored / obsolete fields:

• codec

Plugin mock

The plugin mock config file (yaml) consists of an array of plugin mock elements. Each plugin mock element consists for the plugin id that should be replaced as well as the Logstash configuration string that should be used as the replacement. This string might be empty. In this case, the mocked plugin is just removed from the Logstash configuration.

Example:

- id: removeme
- id: mockme
  mock: |
    mutate {
      replace => {
        "[message]" => "mocked"
      }
    }

Given the above plugin mock configuration, the plugin with the ID removeme is removed from the Logstash configuration. The plugin with the ID mockme is replaced with the given Logstash configuration.

Migrating to the current test case file format

Originally the input and expected configuration keys were at the top level of the test case file. They were later moved into the testcases key.

To migrate test case files from the old to the new file format the following command using jq can be used (run it in the directory containing the test case files):

for f in *.json ; do
    jq '{ codec, fields, ignore, testcases:[[.input[]], [.expected[]]] | transpose | map({input: [.[0]], expected: [.[1]]})} | with_entries(select(.value != null))' $f > $f.migrated && mv $f.migrated $f
done

This command only works for test case files where there's a one-to-one mapping between the elements of the input array and the elements of the expected array. If you e.g. have drop and/or split filters in your Logstash configuration you'll have to patch the converted test case file by hand afterwards.

Notes

The --sockets flag (Standalone mode)

The command line flag --sockets allows to use unix domain sockets instead of stdin to send the input to Logstash. The advantage of this approach is, that it allows to process test case files in parallel to Logstash, instead of starting a new Logstash instance for every test case file. Because Logstash is known to start slowly, this increases the time needed significantly, especially if there are lots of different test case files.

For the test cases to work properly together with the unix domain socket input, the test case files need to include the property codec set to the value line (or json_lines, if json formatted input should be processed).

The --logstash-arg flag

The --logstash-arg flag is used to supply additional command line arguments or flags for Logstash. Those arguments are not processed by Logstash Filter Verifier other than just forwarding them to Logstash. For flags consisting of a flag name and a value, for both a seperate --logstash-arg in the correct order has to be provided. Because values, starting with one or two dashes (-) are treated as flag by Logstash Filter Verifier, for those flags the value must not be separated using a space but they have to be separated from the flag with the equal sign (=).

For example to set the Logstash node name the following arguments have to be provided to Logstash Filter Verifier:

--logstash-arg=--node.name --logstash-arg MyInstanceName

Logstash compatibility

Standalone mode

Different versions of Logstash behave slightly differently and changes in Logstash may require changes in Logstash Filter Verifier. Upon startup, the program will attempt to auto-detect the version of Logstash used and will use this information to adapt its own behavior.

Starting with Logstash 5.0 finding out the Logstash version is very quick but in previous versions the version string was printed by Ruby code in the JVM so it took several seconds. To avoid this you can use the --logstash-version flag to tell Logstash Filter Verifier which version of Logstash it should expect. Example:

logstash-filter-verifier standalone ... --logstash-version 2.4.0

Daemon mode

In order to use Logstash Filter Verifier in Daemon mode, at least Logstash version 6.7.x is required. Older versions of Logstash are not supported and do not work with Daemon mode.

Windows compatibility

Logstash Filter Verifier has been reported to work on Windows, but this isn't tested by the author and it's not guaranteed to work. There are a couple of known quirks that are easy to work around:

• It won't guess the location of your Logstash executable so you'll have to manually provide it with the --logstash-path flag.
• The default value of the --diff-command is diff -u which won't work on typical Windows machines. You'll have to explicitly select which diff tool to use.

Plugin ID (Daemon mode)

The Daemon mode of Logstash Filter Verifier expects each plugin in the Logstash configuration to have a unique ID. In order to test an existing Logstash configuration, which lacks these ID, there are two options:

1. Permanently add the missing ID to the configuration. This can either be done by hand or with the help of mustache.

   mustache lint --auto-fix-id <Logstash config files>
   

2. Let Logstash Filter Verifier add the ID temporarily just for the execution of the test cases by adding the flag --add-missing-id.

Logstash Plugins

Clone (Filter)

LFV configures Logstash such that the ordering of the events while being processed by the pipeline is ensured. In this regard, the clone filter is special, because it injects additional events into the processing pipeline.

The cloned events can be expected in the following order:

1. original event
2. clones of the event in the order of appearance in the clones attribute of the clone filter.

@metadata field

Events in Logstash have a special field called @metadata. The contents of @metadata are not part of any of your events at output time. LFV does make use of @metadata to store information, which is required to control the processing of the events. To ensure the correct operation of LFV, the Logstash configuration under test is not allowed to alter any field within the @metadata, which start with __lfv_. For example the following fields are used by LFV (not conclusive):

• [@metadata][__lfv_id]
• [@metadata][__lfv_out_passed]

These fields are also removed from @metadata even when the test case definition does include export_metadata.

Additionally, all fields within @metadata starting with __tmp_ are removed.

For debug purposes, the --debug flag may be passed, which prevents the removal of the above mentioned fields.

Development

Dependencies

For a fully working development environment, the following tooling needs to be present:

• Go compiler
• make command
• Proto buffer compiler (protobuf-compiler)

Run Integration Tests

In order to run the integration tests, the following preparation is needed:

1. Run go run . setup 8.12.1 to download Logstash version 8.12.1

2. Prepare a logstash-filter-verifier.yml config file, which points to the downloaded Logstash version, e.g.

   ---
   
   loglevel: debug
   logstash:
     path: ./3rdparty/logstash-8.12.1-linux-x86_64/bin/logstash
   keep-envs:
     - TESTMODE
   metadata-key: __metadata

3. Execute the integration tests by providing the respective env var:

   INTEGRATION_TEST=1 go test -v .

   or

   export INTEGRATION_TEST=1
   go test -v .

Known limitations and future work

• Some log formats don't include all timestamp components. For example, most syslog formats don't include the year. This should be dealt with somehow.
• Logstash configurations, which remove the @timestamp field can not be tested using the daemon mode (see #151).
• The maximum size of events, that can be processed is ~64KB (see #169).

License

This software is copyright 2015–2021 by Magnus Bäck <[email protected]> and other contributors and licensed under the Apache 2.0 license. See the LICENSE file for the full license text.